Pirate Party: Are Americans losing something in translation here?

A Sadien.com Editorial

I've seen this story about the "EU Pirate Party" floating around for several days now.

Piracy is bad. No question about it. (And before all of the Pro-Pirate-Bay-Copyright-Sucks-I-Dont-Wanna-Pay-For-Stuff people start throwing a tantrum over that statement, I believe the bigger question is, "What is an appropriate definition of piracy?")

Copyright holders should have an absolute right to protect their content, and distribute it as they see fit. If they wish to charge for it, great. If they wish to give it away for free, that's great too.

The point is, it should be the copyright holder's choice. Period. The exact same way that if you go to work... you get paid. If you donate your time to a cause... it's charity.

Forcing an individual or entity to GIVE AWAY their work-product, is slavery. And, I mean that literally, by definition.

If you have a 25 year old man. And you force him work for 100's of hours to create a "widget"... then gave it away to the public for free... with no compensation to the young man... every special-interest group on the planet would be screaming the words "slavery" and "human rights violations" on behalf of the young workman.

Yet, when that "young man" is a multi-billion dollar content provider... the entire mood shifts to "Screw 'em. They've got the money."

Is this fair?

Please understand, my group is NOT, ABSOLUTELY NOT, an advocate for "big-software," "Hollywood," or any other commercial group. We believe those groups can be unfair, unethical, and use heavy-handed tactics to push their own agenda.

Our opinion is that content providers and content users should co-exist in a mutually beneficial, peaceful relationship.

Which brings me back to my original premise, are we losing something in translation on this topic?

I mean, they're called "The Pirate Party." The American definition of "piracy," is "illegal theft."

It stands to reason that people (specifically Americans) might question a "Piracy Party" being elected to any office. They same way we would question political parties named "The Kitten Kickers" or "The Grandma Haters."

Did the EU just fill a political seat with a known, willful criminal element? Or are we missing something here?

Sadien Staff
Sadien, Inc.
http://www.sadien.com

Views: 47

Reply to This

Happy 10th year, JCertif!

Notes

Welcome to Codetown!

Codetown is a social network. It's got blogs, forums, groups, personal pages and more! You might think of Codetown as a funky camper van with lots of compartments for your stuff and a great multimedia system, too! Best of all, Codetown has room for all of your friends.

When you create a profile for yourself you get a personal page automatically. That's where you can be creative and do your own thing. People who want to get to know you will click on your name or picture and…
Continue

Created by Michael Levin Dec 18, 2008 at 6:56pm. Last updated by Michael Levin May 4, 2018.

Looking for Jobs or Staff?

Check out the Codetown Jobs group.

 

Enjoy the site? Support Codetown with your donation.



InfoQ Reading List

Java News Roundup: CLI Tool for Quarkus MCP, Groovy 5.0 Milestone, JHipster, GraalVM

This week's Java roundup for July 21st, 2025, features news highlighting: a new tool to use Quarkus MCP Client to access a secure Quarkus MCP Server from the command line; the second beta release of Groovy 5.0.0; and point releases for GraalVM Native Build Tools and JHipster Lite.

By Michael Redlich

Apple Shares Details on Upcoming AI Foundation Models for iOS 26

In a recent tech report, Apple has provided more details on the performance and characteristics of the new Apple Intelligence Foundation Models that will be part of iOS 26, as announced at the latest WWDC 2025.

By Sergio De Simone

The White House Releases National AI Strategy Focused on Innovation, Infrastructure, and Global Lead

The White House has published America’s AI Action Plan, outlining a national strategy to enhance U.S. leadership in artificial intelligence. The plan follows President Trump’s January Executive Order 14179, which directed federal agencies to accelerate AI development and remove regulatory barriers to innovation.

By Robert Krzaczyński

Spring News Roundup: Milestone Releases of Boot, Security, Auth Server, GraphQL, Kafka, Pulsar

There was a flurry of activity in the Spring ecosystem during the week of July 21st, 2025, highlighting milestone releases of Spring Boot, Spring Security, Spring Authorization Server, Spring for GraphQL, Spring Session, Spring Integration, Spring REST Docs, Spring Batch, Spring AMQP, Spring for Apache Kafka, Spring for Apache Pulsar and Spring Web Services.

By Michael Redlich

Vercel Adds External API Caching Analytics to Observability

Vercel has enhanced its observability platform by integrating external API caching insights, enabling developers to track how many requests to third-party APIs are served from the Vercel Data Cache versus being routed to the origin server.

By Craig Risi

© 2025   Created by Michael Levin.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service