Pirate Party: Are Americans losing something in translation here?

A Sadien.com Editorial

I've seen this story about the "EU Pirate Party" floating around for several days now.

Piracy is bad. No question about it. (And before all of the Pro-Pirate-Bay-Copyright-Sucks-I-Dont-Wanna-Pay-For-Stuff people start throwing a tantrum over that statement, I believe the bigger question is, "What is an appropriate definition of piracy?")

Copyright holders should have an absolute right to protect their content, and distribute it as they see fit. If they wish to charge for it, great. If they wish to give it away for free, that's great too.

The point is, it should be the copyright holder's choice. Period. The exact same way that if you go to work... you get paid. If you donate your time to a cause... it's charity.

Forcing an individual or entity to GIVE AWAY their work-product, is slavery. And, I mean that literally, by definition.

If you have a 25 year old man. And you force him work for 100's of hours to create a "widget"... then gave it away to the public for free... with no compensation to the young man... every special-interest group on the planet would be screaming the words "slavery" and "human rights violations" on behalf of the young workman.

Yet, when that "young man" is a multi-billion dollar content provider... the entire mood shifts to "Screw 'em. They've got the money."

Is this fair?

Please understand, my group is NOT, ABSOLUTELY NOT, an advocate for "big-software," "Hollywood," or any other commercial group. We believe those groups can be unfair, unethical, and use heavy-handed tactics to push their own agenda.

Our opinion is that content providers and content users should co-exist in a mutually beneficial, peaceful relationship.

Which brings me back to my original premise, are we losing something in translation on this topic?

I mean, they're called "The Pirate Party." The American definition of "piracy," is "illegal theft."

It stands to reason that people (specifically Americans) might question a "Piracy Party" being elected to any office. They same way we would question political parties named "The Kitten Kickers" or "The Grandma Haters."

Did the EU just fill a political seat with a known, willful criminal element? Or are we missing something here?

Sadien Staff
Sadien, Inc.
http://www.sadien.com

Views: 43

Reply to This

Happy 10th year, JCertif!

Notes

Welcome to Codetown!

Codetown is a social network. It's got blogs, forums, groups, personal pages and more! You might think of Codetown as a funky camper van with lots of compartments for your stuff and a great multimedia system, too! Best of all, Codetown has room for all of your friends.

When you create a profile for yourself you get a personal page automatically. That's where you can be creative and do your own thing. People who want to get to know you will click on your name or picture and…
Continue

Created by Michael Levin Dec 18, 2008 at 6:56pm. Last updated by Michael Levin May 4, 2018.

Looking for Jobs or Staff?

Check out the Codetown Jobs group.

 

Enjoy the site? Support Codetown with your donation.



InfoQ Reading List

KubeCon EU: Backstage, Crossplane and Others Preparing for CNCF Graduation

More projects from the CNCF incubated level are preparing to graduate for an ever-widening cloud native ecosystem. The Backstage community has worked on a more robust architecture, and Crossplane aimed to improve its developer DX. KubeFlow and Volcano, both tools promising to improve AI adoption within the Kubernetes ecosystem, are working on easier installation and more features, respectively.

By Olimpiu Pop

How to Tame Technical Debt in Software Development

According to Marijn Huizenveld, discipline is key to preventing accumulating technical debt. In order to be disciplined you should make it difficult to ignore the debt. Heuristics like fixing small issues immediately, agreeing on a timebox for improvement, and making messy things look messy, can help tame technical debt.

By Ben Linders

xAI Opens Grok as an Open-Source Model

Elon Musk announced that xAI would make its AI chatbot Grok open source, and now the release is accessible on GitHub and Hugging Face. This move enables researchers and developers to expand upon the model, influencing how xAI evolves Grok in the face of competition from tech giants like OpenAI, Meta, Google, Microsoft, and others.

By Daniel Dominguez

Presentation: Portfolio Analysis at Scale: Running Risk and Analytics on 15+ Million Portfolios Every Day

William Chen discusses the importance of trimming your computational graph, storing data in multiple formats, leveraging open source, and considering multiple dimensions of modularization.

By William Chen

Redis Switches to SSPLv1: Restrictive License Sparks Fork by Former Maintainers

Redis has recently announced a change in their license by transitioning from the open-source BSD to the more restrictive Server Side Public License (SSPLv1). The move has promptly led to a fork initiated by former maintainers and reignited discussions surrounding the sustainability of open-source initiatives.

By Renato Losio

© 2024   Created by Michael Levin.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service